I'm fine with eyeliner and a little makeup, like when you can't even tell it's there.
I've always hated standing in line at Walmart or the grocery store. On the cover of virtually every magazine is a girl shaped like a toothpick with a plastic face. I've always been a little counter-culture but to me that's beyond what should be acceptable for popular culture.
My wife seldom wears makeup and IMHO, she never looks better with it. It always takes away from the fact that she's freaking gorgeous. Without it.
Edit. Additionally, I don't like toothpicks. Women should have curves. My wife recently lost a bunch of weight and she's on the cusp of being a toothpick. I don't even know how many times I've told her to stop losing weight. I'm not saying women should be overweight, but pop culture's idea of healthy is totally different from common sense. Women shouldn't look like 10 year old boys. End of rant.